The Right of First Refusal in Parenting Plans

BLOG

The Right of First Refusal in Parenting Plans

Many people going through a divorce try to get as much parenting time with their children as possible.  While people may think that this is limited to receiving a 50/50 parenting time schedule, there are other ways to increase the amount of time the child spends with a parent.  On April 10, 2017, the Appellate Division addressed one way to do this, known as the “right of first refusal” in Ferrer v. Durkin.

What is the right of first refusal?

The right of first refusal means that if a parent cannot be physically present with the children during his or her parenting time, they must offer the time to the other parent prior to getting a babysitter.  For example, if Mom has parenting time on Mondays, but works until 8 p.m., she would have to offer Dad parenting time from after school until she returns at 8 p.m.

In many cases, parties who choose to include a right of first refusal define exactly when and how it is to be used.  For example, if the custodial parent cannot be there for more than a certain time frame, such as 6 hours or maybe overnight, then the other parent has to be offered the right to have the child during that time.  Defining the time frame like this avoids issues when you might want to leave a child alone for a shorter time – such as going to the gym or food shopping.  Being careful about the terms makes it easier to understand exactly what the other parent’s expectation is with regard to these events.  In cases where communication between the parties is poor, failing to properly define a time frame inevitably leads to arguments.

Ferrer v. Durkin Decision

In this case, the parties agreed to 50/50 custody of their children.  The parties lived within 2 miles of each other, which made this a very workable schedule.  Mr. Durkin refused to settle the custody portion of the case over two relatively minor issues: a vacation schedule and the right of first refusal.

Due to Mr. Durkin’s refusal to reach a settlement on these issues, it was necessary to hold a trial.  During the trial, Ms. Ferrer testified that she works as a nurse and has her parents and/or Mr. Durkin’s sister watch the children when she is unavailable.  Mr. Durkin claimed that it was his constitutional right as a father to be permitted to spend additional time with his children.  Further, he argued it was a violation of his rights if the trial court permitted the extended family to babysit when he was available during Ms. Ferrer’s parenting time.

The trial court applied the “best interest” standard, which means that it evaluated the case based on what it believed was in the best interest of the children.  The judge also evaluated the demeanor and credibility of the parties during trial.  Ultimately, the court determined that the inability of the parties to reach an agreement on the issues was due largely to Mr. Durkin’s refusal to compromise his position.  The judge also felt that Mr. Durkin was using the trial to attempt to smear his ex-wife’s reputation.

The trial court judge determined that the parties’ inability to communicate and agree on issues with the children was the overriding reason why the right of first refusal was not workable.  Therefore, the trial court denied Mr. Durkin’s request that a right of first refusal be included in the parenting plan.  The Appellate Division agreed.  If the parties were able to communicate, cooperate, and compromise effectively, which is generally understood to be in the children’s best interest, there may have been a different outcome.

Establishing a custody and parenting time agreement is often a very emotional and difficult aspect of a divorce.  At DeTorres and DeGeorge, our attorneys handle these issues on a daily basis and have had great success in resolving these matters.  If you need assistance with your divorce and/or custody issues, please contact us today at 908-284-6005 or 973-425-5158 to schedule a consultation with one of our attorneys.

Children & Divorce Guide
About DeTorres and DeGeorge Family Law

DeTorres and DeGeorge Family Law is a New Jersey based family law firm that has been helping New Jersey residents achieve the best possible results in their divorce for nearly 30 years. The DeTorres and DeGeorge Family Law team is always ready to fight for their clients’ rights – determined to help New Jersey families overcome legal challenges from start to finish. Our legal team, with over 65 years of combined experience, provides expert guidance on all family law and divorce-related matters, including custody and parenting time, alimony and child support, equitable distribution of assets, premarital agreements, post-divorce issues, executive compensation distribution, divorces for business owners, and divorce mediation. The firm has been recognized for its dedication and expertise in the industry by multiple local and national organizations, including Super Lawyers, Law Firm 500, and the American Institute of Family Law Attorneys. Rosanne DeTorres, Managing Partner, is one of 150 lawyers certified as a matrimonial law attorney.

Carolyn B. Hand
Carolyn Hand is a passionate and experienced litigator specializing in family law. In 2020, she was named partner at DeTorres & DeGeorge Family Law. Carolyn represents clients in family court in all matters pertaining to divorce, custody...
Share on:

knowledge & insights

Spousal support, maintenance & alimony in a same sex divorce.

Spousal Support, Maintenance & Alimony in a Same Sex Divorce

Many same-sex couples ask us to explain how same sex spousal alimony works in New Jersey. They want to know whether the rules about how much same sex spousal maintenance might be and how long same sex divorce spousal support might be paid are the same as for heterosexual couples.   In...

September 17, 2020 Read More

You can absolutely file for divorce due to domestic violence under the “extreme cruelty” ground for divorce.

SEPARATION & DIVORCE AFTER DOMESTIC VIOLENCE

During COVID, there has been an exponential increase in the number of domestic violence and divorce cases. We know that partners and spouses who are cooped up in the same home for a long period of time provide a breeding ground for poor behavior to turn into domestic violence. We often see victims...

September 15, 2020 Read More

Same sex couple discussing second parent adoption with child

Second Parent Adoption

A second parent adoption is a legal procedure that allows a same-sex parent, regardless of whether they have a legally recognized relationship to the other parent, to adopt her or his partner's biological or adoptive child without terminating the first parent’s legal status as a parent. Married...

August 13, 2020 Read More

Divorce: The Answers you Need – Before, During & After

Download our eBook today!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Newsletter

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
follow us
Top