The Appellate Division Upholds Parent’s Rights in Non-Dissolution Matters

BLOG

The Appellate Division Upholds Parent’s Rights in Non-Dissolution Matters

The Appellate Division Upholds Parent’s Rights in Non-Dissolution MattersThe Appellate court has overturned a trial court decision where the judge decided an issue of custody of a child born to parents who were never married without permitting sufficient discovery and testimony by the parents and their counsel. On January 2, 2019, the Appellate Division of the Superior Court of New Jersey issued a reported decision in the matter of J.G. v. J.H.– a case in which the parties were never married but had a child together during their dating relationship. The child, who at the time of the litigation was 4 years old, had primarily lived with his mother since the parties broke up. When Mother became involved in a new relationship, Father filed an emergent application seeking custody of the child based on his representations that Mother’s new boyfriend was a drug user and had served time in prison. The judge awarded temporary custody to Father.

When the parties appeared for their hearing date, the judge swore in each of the parties and went back and forth between them, asking questions in an effort to determine the facts. Mother appeared with an attorney, but the judge did not let the attorney participate in the proceedings. After hearing conflicting testimony from the parties and denying Mother’s counsel’s request for discovery, the judge issued a decision granting Father primary custody and setting a parenting time schedule for Mother.

In cases in which the parties were never married but have children in common, applications to the court are considered to be “FD” or “non-dissolution” matters. Under the Court Rules, they are considered summary proceedings, generally meaning that they are to be resolved within a limited period of time. Most summary proceedings do not allow a party the right to conduct discovery as such cases limited in scope and usually relatively easy to resolve. However, Court Rule 5:5-7 provides that a party may make an application, or the court may decide on its own, that an FD case may be set on a complex track, which would then include the right to exchange of discovery and expert evaluations. The complex track is generally reserved for those cases that are too complex to be determined in the normal course of a summary proceeding – a designation that likely should have been applied in the case of J.G. vs. J.H.

Instead, in J.G. v. J.H., the judge outright denied Mother’s counsel’s request to designate the case as complex, which was sought due to the serious questions of custody and parenting time that warranted an exchange of discovery and potentially the retention of expert witnesses. According to the Appellate Division, at the very least the Court should have referred the case to custody and parenting time mediation or taken further steps to investigate. The trial judge also did not address the specific factors of the custody statute in his decision, instead simply noting that the child had already been uprooted once. The trial court’s decision was a disservice not only to the parents, but also to the 4-year-old child whose best interests should have been at the forefront of its concern.

This case is important because the Appellate Division took a stand against the tendency to dismiss FD matters as simple or unimportant compared to those issues raised in the context of more complex cases like divorce. While FD matters generally do not include as many financial aspects as a divorce, there are often significant and important aspects of the case that should not be decided summarily, as was done in this case. Specifically, the best interests of the children involved should have been evaluated and weighed by the judge with the same scrutiny as the best interests of children whose parents are married. The courts owe this not only to the parents who are litigants in the court system, but also to the children they are charged with protecting.

If you have a FD matter that you would like to discuss with the attorneys of DeTorres & DeGeorge, schedule a consultation today.

Children & Divorce Guide
About DeTorres and DeGeorge Family Law

DeTorres and DeGeorge Family Law is a New Jersey based family law firm that has been helping New Jersey residents achieve the best possible results in their divorce for nearly 30 years. The DeTorres and DeGeorge Family Law team is always ready to fight for their clients’ rights – determined to help New Jersey families overcome legal challenges from start to finish. Our legal team, with over 65 years of combined experience, provides expert guidance on all family law and divorce-related matters, including custody and parenting time, alimony and child support, equitable distribution of assets, premarital agreements, post-divorce issues, executive compensation distribution, divorces for business owners, and divorce mediation. The firm has been recognized for its dedication and expertise in the industry by multiple local and national organizations, including Super Lawyers, Law Firm 500, and the American Institute of Family Law Attorneys. Rosanne DeTorres, Managing Partner, is one of 150 lawyers certified as a matrimonial law attorney.

Erin D. DeGeorge
Erin D. DeGeorge joined DeTorres & DeGeorge, LLC as partner to the firm in June of 2010. Prior to joining DeTorres & DeGeorge, Erin was associated with the national firm of Fox Rothschild LLP and Cutler, Simeone, Townsend, Tomaio & Newmark, LLC...
Share on:

knowledge & insights

Sign that says Business Closed

Closing a Business During a Divorce

In New Jersey, the businesses of the spouses are equitably divided when they divorce - if the businesses are marital property. Any business that was started after the spouse married is likely to be considered marital property. If you own a business before you marry, the increase in value of the...

October 20, 2021 Read More

Road sign displaying marriage one way and divorce the other way.

Signs You Are Ready For Divorce

It’s not easy admitting that your marriage is over. It’s not easy making the decision to move forward. Many times though, staying in a loveless marriage or a marriage where you and your spouse have moved in different directions isn’t an option. So, how do you know when you are ready for a...

September 2, 2021 Read More

Graphic displaying a father and mother discussing a parenting plan.

Parenting Plan Modification

Parents can’t relax just because they have a custody order and a well-crafted parenting plan. Circumstances often change. The children develop new needs. Divorced spouses develop new relationships. Changes to an existing parenting plan may be necessary. Parents can agree to a parenting plan...

July 20, 2021 Read More

Divorce: The Answers you Need – Before, During & After

Download our eBook today!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Newsletter

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

follow us
Top