What Happens If There Is No Custody Agreement

BLOG

What Happens If There Is No Custody Agreement

Understanding custody without orders in New Jersey

The best course of action for any parent who is divorcing their spouse or living apart from the other biological parent is to obtain a New Jersey custody order. A custody order determines which parents have legal custody and which parents have physical custody. A formally approved parenting plan/custody agreement sets forth exactly when each child will live with each parent.

What happens if there is no custody agreement can be quite scary. For starters, if there is no custody agreement as to who has custody, then the police or state law enforcement will not be able to intervene forcefully on your behalf. If there is no legal custody agreement as to who has custody, then there is no way for the police to know if your child should be with you or with the other parent. This means that if the father or mother refuses to return the child to you or worse leaves the state, you will need to use the courts to enforce your rights and protect your child.

What happens if there is no custody agreement affects your rights and your child’s in several respects:

  •       If you and your spouse or co-parent have an informal understanding about when the child should be exchanged, you cannot enforce that understanding unless you obtain a formal custody order.
  •       If you and your spouse or co-parent have an oral agreement (but not one in writing), then the other parent could deny your right to speak with your child while the child is with the other parent.
  •       What happens if there is no custody agreement becomes especially nightmarish if the other parent leaves New Jersey. When will you see your child? How can you force a father or mother to return the child to New Jersey?

The question of what happens if there is no custody agreement is generally different if the parents are married or if they are unmarried.

What happens if there is no custody agreement and a father/husband takes the child without the mother’s consent/permission?

If a father has no right to take the child (based on current New Jersey Law), then you should consider:

  •       Calling an experienced New Jersey lawyer
  •       Calling the police though it is not clear what they can do without a formal custody agreement. The police could try to locate the child and let you know if the father did indeed take the child.
  •       Contact National Center for Missing and Exploited Children

Generally, married parents have joint custody of the children which means one parent could take the child, when you’re separate, at any time. If a married parent takes a child without your permission or knowledge, that act could be used against your husband/wife when you do formally request custody of your children. The family law judge can consider past actions in awarding custody and visitation.

Generally, unmarried fathers cannot take a child away from a mother. Unmarried mothers are presumed to have custody of their children – at least until the father proves paternity and files a petition for custody. [I’m not sure if this is the law in NJ?]. Without a custody order, the mother could file criminal charges against the father. The mother could also notify the police who would have the authority to investigate the whereabouts of the child and return the child to the mother.

What happens if there is no custody agreement varies depending on the marital status

As discussed above, there is a presumption that both married parents have joint custody of children and a presumption that only the mother has custody if the parents are not married. If the parents are going through a divorce, then a judge can order temporary custody of the child with one or both parents – while the divorce is pending.

What happens if there is no custody agreement affects the filing of criminal charges. If a parent takes a child when it is clear that he/she does not have custody, the parent could be charged with kidnapping.

Child support and the issue of – what happens if there is no custody agreement

Another issue to review with an experienced New Jersey family lawyer is whether the other parent owes a duty of support if there is not a determination of custody. If parents are married but separated or married and filing for divorce, then generally a parent can seek child support. While the non-custodial parent normally owes a duty to provide financial support for his/her child, the amount of the child support often is based on the child custody agreement. That is because, in fairness, there is a big difference between a child who lives with one parent seven days a week and a child who lives with a parent four days a week. If the parent lives with you seven days a week, the other parent should be more in child support than if the coparent is also providing for the child’s daily needs three days a week.

For this is reason, it is good for both parents to establish child custody because child custody helps to determine the amount of child support. What happens if there is no custody agreement is that a child support order can be entered – but it is generally less firm and less stable than if there is a child custody agreement.

At DeTorres & DeGeorge Family Law, our lawyers have 20 years of family law experience. We understand what happens if there is no custody agreement. We seek to negotiate custody agreements or litigate custody orders in court. Our general advice to clients who ask – what happens if there is no custody agreement is to obtain a custody agreement as soon as possible. To discuss your custody and visitation rights, call us at 908-691-2104 or use our contact form to discuss your rights. We have offices in Clinton and Morristown.

 

Caitlin DeGuilo Toker
Caitlin DeGuilo Toker joined DeTorres and DeGeorge as an associate attorney in June 2014 and was named a partner of the firm in May 2019.Prior to joining the firm, Caitlin was associated with law firms specializing in the practice of family ...
Share on:

knowledge & insights

Is Recording Phone Conversations In New Jersey Legal?

If you are involved in a divorce, you may want to know if  recording phone conversations in New Jersey is legal and if these conversations are admissible in court. This is a complex question and one that requires consultation with a skilled family law attorney. New Jersey phone recording law does...

August 10, 2022 Read More

Couple sitting on sofa signing documents

Do Prenups Actually Hold Up in Court in New Jersey?

If you live in New Jersey and you are wondering whether you need a prenuptial agreement and whether prenups actually hold up in court or how long prenups last, you are not alone. Oftentimes, when people are planning to marry, they discuss whether or not a prenup is necessary. Some questions that...

June 7, 2022 Read More

Divorce decree with rings and gavel

Can a Divorce be Reopened in New Jersey?

There are limited circumstances that will allow someone to reopen a divorce in the state of New Jersey. If you are wondering, can a divorce be reopened, you are not alone. There are many people who ask this question each year as modifications and changes to the divorce determination become logical....

June 3, 2022 Read More

Divorce: The Answers you Need – Before, During & After

Download our eBook today!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Newsletter

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

follow us
Top